The opportunity to vote - employee advantage for nightmare?
In a season of television ads ensuring we exercise our right to vote, a
new type of voting is beginning to appear in the business environment. No, employees are not telling their employers
what political candidate they find the most appealing, they are deciding
workplace solutions with the democratic process. In an article
published in the Wall Street Journal, Workplace Democracy Catches On, we find that many employers are finding ways to
engage employees by asking them to vote on items from important to trivial
matters. Most employees have never had
the opportunity to voice their opinion on many of these items and find both
positives and negatives with the voting process. Questions about better vending machines, whether
to play music in the common area to having a holiday party are now being directed
to the employees for their vote.
The articles author, Rachel Emma Silverman, shares a few companies where
this ‘workplace democracy’ has caught on.
These companies include, InContext, Whole Foods Market Inc., and
MediaMath Inc. Using “digital survey
tools like TinyPulse and Know You Company enable more companies to give their
staff a voice in running the workplace” Silverman (2016). Mackenzie Siren, a manager at InContext,
said, “People feel like they have a real voice” as decisions were made whether
to have cubicles or open tables, standing desks and which type of coffee to
brew.
This new type of employee engagement appears to be beneficial. Providing employees an opportunity to voice
their opinion on a variety of issues helps to create loyalty to the
company. When employees have a say in
something, even if their individual decision is not the one picked, they are more likely to be
engaged in the outcome. Having an
opportunity to have a ‘say’ is new for most employees and can be very
beneficial in employee morale and engagement.
Will all employee engage in the democratic voting process for their workplace? Those companies that have instituted employee democracy have found that there are some negatives. Sure, voter fatigue plays a part. Employees can feel questions can be too cumbersome and may feel indifferent to the question or cause. In addition, if the weight of the question is significant, employees may shy away from casting their vote. An example of this is hiring a new CEO. But the biggest impact, good or bad, comes from management's attitude toward the voting process. If managers discredit the voting process, employees are less likely to play a role and the opposite is true, managers who encourage employees to voice their opinion find a higher percentage of those who vote.
Employee voting = management nightmare? Offering workplace democracy causes many HR professionals to cringe. Sure, they will all say that they want employee engagement, but most dread hearing the negative. In addition, management often will cite worries about handing over decision making to the average employee. Sure, most managers are control freaks - and the idea of giving away some control is a frightening concept. The possibility of giving employees decision making opportunities that can affect what management does, even small issues, turn into a horrendous process? Turns out, the answer is no - employee engagement makes for a better workplace environment and better managers!
Will all employee engage in the democratic voting process for their workplace? Those companies that have instituted employee democracy have found that there are some negatives. Sure, voter fatigue plays a part. Employees can feel questions can be too cumbersome and may feel indifferent to the question or cause. In addition, if the weight of the question is significant, employees may shy away from casting their vote. An example of this is hiring a new CEO. But the biggest impact, good or bad, comes from management's attitude toward the voting process. If managers discredit the voting process, employees are less likely to play a role and the opposite is true, managers who encourage employees to voice their opinion find a higher percentage of those who vote.
Employee voting = management nightmare? Offering workplace democracy causes many HR professionals to cringe. Sure, they will all say that they want employee engagement, but most dread hearing the negative. In addition, management often will cite worries about handing over decision making to the average employee. Sure, most managers are control freaks - and the idea of giving away some control is a frightening concept. The possibility of giving employees decision making opportunities that can affect what management does, even small issues, turn into a horrendous process? Turns out, the answer is no - employee engagement makes for a better workplace environment and better managers!
The decision to integrate a workplace democracy is a new, interesting
management tool that every business could benefit from, IF managed correctly. Managers and top executives must decide what
type of decisions they will empower the employees with. Choosing the next CEO or choosing the snacks
in the break room offer a vast difference in employee democratic power, although
both can have a positive effect for the employees. An example shared in the article comes from
1Sale.com. The employees were asked
whether the company should continue serving free lunch or apply the lunch costs
to lowering their health insurance premiums.
A resounding 90% of employees chose to have lower health insurance
premiums. This decision did not cost the
company any additional money but they received employee buy-in on the most
beneficial way to spend the money for the employees.
Asking for employee engagement offer a new level of empowerment for the
employee and the managers. When the
managers know the direction that employees want to go, managers have a better
ability to accomplish goals. In
addition, with employee engagement, it’s much harder for employees to complain
about decisions. Engagement helps create
feelings of unity and also brings awareness to workplace benefits and
concerns. Now, employees are part of the
process, which makes for an ideal environment for success.




